A Talent for Murder (2026) *** – Seen at the Cinema

Why don’t we posit Sarah J. Maas as a vet or Ernest Hemingway as a vegetarian or F. Scott Fitzgerald sitting down to lunch in a crummy diner with Jay Gatsby. That’s the kind of reimagining we’re in for here. I’m assuming that the estate of Patricia Highsmith (Strangers on the Train, 1951, The Talented Mr Ripley, 1999 and the source of 42 other movies) have given this fandango their blessing in the hope of shifting more copies of her books.

There’s three narratives in here, any one of which would have made sense on their own, but running all three together results in a shambles, not alleviated by the get-out-of-jail-free twist at the end, but only made watchable by the performances of Oscar-winner Helen Mirren (Mobland TV series 2025-2026) and, to a lesser extent, in a dual role Aiden Ehrenreich (Weapons, 2025).

The trailer was bait-and-switch. I was led to believe that noted crime author Patricia Highsmith (Helen Mirren) was going to find a way to turn mild publishing executive Edward Ridgeway (Aiden Ehrenreich) into a killer. Someone, for example, along the lines of her most infamous creation, murderer Tom Ripley.

Edward is in Switzerland in 1995 because the author’s New York publisher wants her to write another Ripley novel – there are five already – because they are guaranteed best-sellers. She doesn’t want to because she’d rather turn her attention to novels that are more appreciated in Europe than America. For reasons that are unclear, his job is on the line.

She makes short work of ripping apart his credentials, but he gets to stay because – because “legendary” director Anton Corbijn (who hasn’t made a film in over a decade) took a liking for the bizarre screenplay by Joanna Murray Smith (who hasn’t got a film over the starting line in over three decades).

So we’re presented with three overlapping scenarios. In the first, Edward has to assume the fictional mantle of Ripley and effectively provide the plot, including all the evil bits, for the novel he wants her to write. So we have Ripley (also played by a sleeker-looking Ehrenreich) in Rome seducing easily-seduced heiress Clementine Balfour (Olivia Cooke) in order to marry her and kill off the two relatives who are obstacles to her fortune. The first murder is inventive, the second less so.

At the same time, the real Edward has met the real Clementine Balfour and in Ripley-like fashion has to make up a background that fits into her high-flying arty lifestyle and take on a Ripley-like dangerous demeanor in order to seduce a woman who tells him how to seduce her.

So, theoretically, we’re watching Edward turn into Ripley. Or, in the final twist, was he Ripley all along? And in Switzerland to take revenge on his creator, knifing her to death?

I’m not sure what literary category that falls into except a writer desperate to find a way of connecting what initially appear as two quite disparate tales – when in fact they are exceptionally similar – instead of concentrating on one of them, dispensing with Highsmith altogether and getting on with a Ripley-like tale of seduction and murder.

Except that then we’d be left with just Ehrenreich and Cooke and neither of their characters would make this movie fly. She’s just way too weak a character, in either of her roles. While he’s less so, he’s not that convincing as a killer.

More to the point, exclude Highsmith and there wouldn’t be much left. She’s such a mean twisted character she’s an absolute delight. Not only does she flood a guest bedroom with snails but she’s apt to cut a guest’s neck with a very sharp knife (one that he’s brought as a gift) while he’s sleeping. There’s no question she would excel in warping an innocent mind, finding the triggers to turn a mild person into a killer.

That’s what the director should have concentrated upon. He would’ve easily got away with making the Mirren character someone who resembles Highsmith, found another reason for the guest to visit, and then let loose the warped mind on the innocent one.

As it is, it’s a curate’s egg, good in the scenes containing Mirren, less so when she’s absent.

Mirren is excellent and well worth the price of admission. Ehrenreich makes a plausible-enough transition, but not enough to convince, but Olivia Cooke (House of the Dragon TV series 2022-2026) has very little material to play with except be the patsy.

Unknown's avatar

Author: Brian Hannan

I am a published author of books about film - over a dozen to my name, the latest being "When Women Ruled Hollywood." As the title of the blog suggests, this is a site devoted to movies of the 1960s but since I go to the movies twice a week - an old-fashioned double-bill of my own choosing - I might occasionally slip in a review of a contemporary picture.

Leave a Reply

Discover WordPress

A daily selection of the best content published on WordPress, collected for you by humans who love to read.

The Atavist Magazine

by Brian Hannan

WordPress.com Blog

News, Tips & Website Tutorials