Yeah, couldn’t resist catching up on this after seeing its 50th anniversary tribute movie I Play Rocky (2026). It’s much darker than I remember and I can clearly see what attracted producers Irwin Winkler and Robert Chartoff to the screenplay. It’s not just a modern fairy tale where the little guy – in the American Way, apparently – is given his chance and not just a great boxing movie, but it’s about those struggling on the verge of becoming the dregs of society and about being left out and ignored.
Most times when Hollywood examines poverty, it’s about the unemployed or people with lives inhibited by some other obstacle, disability, alcohol, unfaithfulness, perhaps all three. But this is about those inhabiting some kind of twilight zone where the chance of falling through onto skid row are very high. At best, they’re making do. At worse, they wonder why their ambitions – which might be just as ordinary as falling in love – are being denied.

As much as it plays into The American Dream, the screenplay recognizes that darkness. You can see what Chartoff and Winkler saw when they read a piece in which each of the four principles gets to talk about loss, about being ignored, about being erased from The American Dream.
Perhaps the most famous of these is the “what about my prime” tirade by Rocky (Sylvester Stallone) when he nearly knocks a door off its hinges in his fury. But that was preceded by Rocky’s 76-year-old trainer Mickey (Burgess Meredith) and his outburst about, effectively, how with a little help he could have become a contender and instead is left with all the physical scars of his failure.
In some sense he represents the Ghost of Xmas Future, revealing to Rocky what he’ll become if he doesn’t buckle down and take the help that’s offered. The conclusion to that sequence is brilliantly done. In extreme long-shot and resisting the temptation (perhaps imposed by budget restrictions) of a single close-up we see the pair on a dark deserted street reconcile.

Rocky’s meek girlfriend pet-shop worker Adrian (Talia Shire) realizes her brother Paulie (Burt Young) has deliberately reinforced her negative feelings about herself so that he’ll gain a permanent housekeeper and to the audience’s surprise she kicks off the traces and gives him both barrels. Perhaps saddest of all is alcoholic lonely unmarried Paulie, who appears to have no redeeming features, but is clearly cursed with the same negative thoughts as his sister and can’t understand why he’s been cast aside.
So that’s mostly what this movie is about, not one guy/gal being given the opportunity to stand up for himself/herself, to move out of one of the lowest circles of hell, but through Rocky all achieve a more satisfying level of existence and begin to realize long-held ambition and not to be left out.
Luckily, the rest of the tale measures up and it just doesn’t settle to examining the grim reality of the American working poor. Mickey’s simple methods of improving Rocky’s boxing technique, Adrian throwing off years or self-restraint and self-doubt by just lunging into kissing Rocky when the opportunity arises, Paulie with a cigar and a woman at his side when he manages to score some sponsorship cash off (literally) the back of Rocky.
This works as well because it takes a long time to get going, doesn’t just jump straight in. So we see what Rocky lacks. He doesn’t have what it takes to be a big-time boxer – the fact that his nose isn’t broken tells you he’s never truly got into the heat of a fight – nor sufficient toughness of another kind to be an enforcer for a loan shark, nor even the kind of self-confidence that you’d expect a boxer to have when it came to women.
His personal development lends itself to cinema. The lonely pounding of the streets, the physical exertions of training, the exhausted crawl up the steps that turns into hope and fires up the local crowd. The exultation when he raises his hands aloft in triumph atop the steps is pure expression of self-belief.
The fight itself is bloodily terrific, the cocky Apollo Creed (Carl Weathers) who (literally) gets a come-uppance in the ring as Rocky expresses every ounce of ambition and hope.
Terrific performances all round. Stallone might appear at his best with the smart lines that woo Adrian or the hammering he takes in training or in the ring. But he’s at his best when the camera settles on his face and reveals the depth of his despair. He was the only one of the four principles not to be recognised by an Oscar nomination and Meredith actually won.
And you’d have to tip your hand to director John G. Avildsen (Joe, 1970) who made this work on a tiny budget. Not to mention composer Bill Conti. Sure the movie begins with the bold fanfare but mostly the theme tune is picked out on a piano that reinforces loss.
I was worried that Rocky wouldn’t turn out as well as I Play Rocky suggested.
I wasn’t disappointed.
Catch it on Amazon Prime.












